Skip to content
InnoReviews

realme P1 5G vs Redmi 17

WINNER
realme P1 5G
44.3Inno Score
VS
Redmi 17

Xiaomi

Redmi 17
40.2Inno Score
28.9Performance20
58.2Display40.9
30.7Camera29
52.5Battery71.3
73.3Features60
8 spec wins — realme P1 5G3 spec wins — Redmi 17

InnoReviews verdict

realme P1 5G wins this phone face-off, 44.3 to 40.2, pulling ahead mainly in display (+17) and features (+13). Redmi 17 still makes sense if its price or standout specs fit your needs better.

Which would you pick?

Key differences

Reasons to pick the realme P1 5G

  • Stronger performance score: 29 vs 20
  • Stronger display score: 58 vs 41
  • Stronger features score: 73 vs 60
  • 142% higher Peak brightness: 2,000 nits vs 825 nits
  • 100% higher Front camera: 16 MP vs 8 MP

Reasons to pick the Redmi 17

  • Stronger battery score: 71 vs 53
  • 50% higher capacity: 7,500 mAh vs 5,000 mAh
  • Has NFC — the other doesn't

Display

Display comparison: realme P1 5G versus Redmi 17
Specrealme P1 5GRedmi 17
Screen size6.67 ″6.9 ″+3%
Panel typeAMOLEDIPS LCD
Resolution1080x2400720x1600
Pixel density395 ppi+56%254 ppi
Refresh rate120 Hz120 Hz
Peak brightness2,000 nits+142%825 nits
Screen-to-body92.7 %+7%86.2 %

Performance

Performance comparison: realme P1 5G versus Redmi 17
Specrealme P1 5GRedmi 17
ChipsetMediaTek Dimensity 7050MediaTek Helio G91 Ultra
RAM (max)8 GB+33%6 GB
Storage options128/256GB128/256GB
Storage typeUFS 3.1eMMC 5.1

Camera

Camera comparison: realme P1 5G versus Redmi 17
Specrealme P1 5GRedmi 17
Main camera50 MP50 MP
Main aperturef/1.8f/1.8
Max video4K@30fps1080p@30fps
Front camera16 MP+100%8 MP
OISNoNo

Battery

Battery comparison: realme P1 5G versus Redmi 17
Specrealme P1 5GRedmi 17
Capacity5,000 mAh7,500 mAh+50%
Wired charging45 W45 W

Design

Design comparison: realme P1 5G versus Redmi 17
Specrealme P1 5GRedmi 17
Weight188 g+19%232 g
Thickness8 mm+9%8.8 mm
IP ratingIP54IP64
Frame materialPlasticPlastic

Connectivity

Connectivity comparison: realme P1 5G versus Redmi 17
Specrealme P1 5GRedmi 17
5GYesNo
Wi-Fi—Wi-Fi 5
Bluetooth5.25.4
NFCNoYes
USBUSB Type-CUSB-C 2.0
eSIM—No

Software

Software comparison: realme P1 5G versus Redmi 17
Specrealme P1 5GRedmi 17
OS at launchAndroid 14 (realme UI 5.0)Android 16 (HyperOS 3)

Audio

Audio comparison: realme P1 5G versus Redmi 17
Specrealme P1 5GRedmi 17
Stereo speakersYesYes
3.5mm jackYesYes

Related comparisons

realme P1 5Gvs iQOO Z11xVSrealme P1 5Gvs Nothing Phone (4b)VSrealme P1 5Gvs OPPO F29 5GVSrealme P1 5Gvs Samsung Galaxy F36 5GVSRedmi 17vs iPhone 12VSRedmi 17vs iPhone 12 miniVSRedmi 17vs Motorola Moto G57 PowerVSRedmi 17vs POCO X3 NFCVS

Try another matchup