Skip to content
InnoReviews

Redmi 17C (China) vs vivo Y58 5G

X
27.9Inno Score
VS
WINNER
vivo Y58 5G
43.5Inno Score
20Performance28.9
38.8Display47
20.5Camera29
40.3Battery61.5
20Features73.3
1 spec wins — Redmi 17C (China)12 spec wins — vivo Y58 5G

InnoReviews verdict

vivo Y58 5G wins this phone face-off, 43.5 to 27.9, pulling ahead mainly in features (+53) and battery (+21). Redmi 17C (China) still makes sense if its price or standout specs fit your needs better.

Which would you pick?

Key differences

Reasons to pick the Redmi 17C (China)

No decisive spec advantages — this side competes on price and preference.

Reasons to pick the vivo Y58 5G

  • Stronger performance score: 29 vs 20
  • Stronger display score: 47 vs 39
  • Stronger camera score: 29 vs 21
  • Stronger battery score: 62 vs 40
  • Stronger features score: 73 vs 20

Display

Display comparison: Redmi 17C (China) versus vivo Y58 5G
SpecRedmi 17C (China)vivo Y58 5G
Screen size6.88 ″+2%6.72 ″
Panel typeIPS LCDIPS LCD
Resolution720x16401080x2408
Pixel density260 ppi393 ppi+51%
Refresh rate120 Hz120 Hz
Peak brightness600 nits1,024 nits+71%
Screen-to-body84 %86.4 %+3%

Performance

Performance comparison: Redmi 17C (China) versus vivo Y58 5G
SpecRedmi 17C (China)vivo Y58 5G
ChipsetMediaTek Helio G81 UltraQualcomm Snapdragon 4 Gen 2
RAM (max)4 GB8 GB+100%
Storage options64/128GB128GB
Storage type—UFS 2.2

Camera

Camera comparison: Redmi 17C (China) versus vivo Y58 5G
SpecRedmi 17C (China)vivo Y58 5G
Main camera13 MP50 MP+285%
Main aperturef/2.2f/1.8
Max video1080p@30fps1080p@30fps
Front camera5 MP8 MP+60%
OISNoNo

Battery

Battery comparison: Redmi 17C (China) versus vivo Y58 5G
SpecRedmi 17C (China)vivo Y58 5G
Capacity5,160 mAh6,000 mAh+16%
Wired charging18 W44 W+144%

Design

Design comparison: Redmi 17C (China) versus vivo Y58 5G
SpecRedmi 17C (China)vivo Y58 5G
Weight206 g199 g+3%
Thickness8.2 mm8 mm+3%
IP rating—IP64
Frame materialPlastic—

Connectivity

Connectivity comparison: Redmi 17C (China) versus vivo Y58 5G
SpecRedmi 17C (China)vivo Y58 5G
5GNoYes
Wi-FiWi-Fi 5Wi-Fi 5
Bluetooth5.45.0
NFCNoNo
USBUSB-C 2.0USB-C 2.0
eSIMNoNo

Software

Software comparison: Redmi 17C (China) versus vivo Y58 5G
SpecRedmi 17C (China)vivo Y58 5G
OS at launchAndroid 16 (HyperOS 3)Android 14 (Funtouch OS 14)

Audio

Audio comparison: Redmi 17C (China) versus vivo Y58 5G
SpecRedmi 17C (China)vivo Y58 5G
Stereo speakersNoYes
3.5mm jackYesYes

Related comparisons

Redmi 17C (China)vs vivo Y18VSRedmi 17C (China)vs Samsung Galaxy A51VSRedmi 17C (China)vs Moto G04VSRedmi 17C (China)vs Redmi Note 8 ProVSvivo Y58 5Gvs Honor X9bVSvivo Y58 5Gvs TECNO SPARK 50 5GVSvivo Y58 5Gvs vivo T3x 5GVSvivo Y58 5Gvs Infinix HOT 50 Pro+VS

Try another matchup